• Log In
Catholicism and Adventism
Discussing Seventh-day Adventism from a Catholic and biblical perspective, and then just some other stuff too
  • Home
  • Intro
    • Mary, the Theotokos
    • Introductory articles
    • About me
    • My views on Adventism
    • Blog rules and ToS
    • Contact
    • Books / videos I recommend
    • Various links
    • Eastern Christianity links
  • The Sabbath
    • The Sabbath – Articles
    • The Old Testament Sabbath and Christians
    • The Sabbath and the First Day in the New Testament
  • Adventist teachings
    • General
    • Prophecy
    • Anti-Catholic propaganda
    • Falsehoods about the Catholic Church
    • Christian holy days
    • The state of the dead
    • Diet and alcohol
    • Adventists and Abortion
    • Baptism
    • Jesus – God or not?
    • The Bible and the Clear Word
    • Ellen White, prophetess
    • Samuele Bacchiocchi
    • Converts from Adventism / Sabbatarianism
  • Catholicism
    • Catholic teaching and defence
    • The Early Church
    • Eastern Christianity
    • The Mass – video collection
    • What Catholics Believe
  • Debates
  • Prophecy
  • Misc topics
    • Books / videos I recommend
    • Herbert Armstrong
    • Mormonism
    • Jehovah’s Witnesses
    • Various links
  • Abortion
  • What Catholics Believe
  • Pope Francis, the Latin Mass … updated
  • Ellen White’s inspiration …
  • Pope Benedict’s final blessing
  • 3 horns and Ostrogoths
  • Pope Sylvester I – who changed the Sabbath?
  • Adventists abusing Socrates
  • Bacchiocchi, 666, VFD
  • Why a bishop may not drink grape juice
  • Is Easter pagan?
  • The Mass – videos
  • Line upon line
  • 1 Cor 16:2 …
  • Statues and idols …
  • Whose truth is the real truth, and how can we know?
  • Catholic discussions on Facebook

About

  • Mary, the Θεοτόκος
  • Blog rules and ToS
  • About me
  • Contact
  • Entries RSS
  • Comments RSS

Free ebook

Free ebook

Click the image

We’re on Facebook!

Catholic discussion of Adventism

Catholic discussion of Adventism

@CatholicAndSDA@CatholicAndSDA

Saint Blogs Parish

New Evangelists Monthly

Scoop.it!

Catholicism and Adventism on Scoop.it!

Subscribe

Subscribe to posts via email [via Wordpress]

Recent posts

  • Michael Scheifler and Pope Vicarius II
  • Jesus our Rising Sun, Light of the World
  • Twitter discussion – an Easter Egg
  • Thus saith Ellen, part 5 – The day and the hour
  • Thus saith Ellen, part 4 – The 10 commandments
  • Thus saith Ellen, part 3 – Jesus is not God
  • Thus saith Ellen, part 2 – Call no man Father?
  • Thus saith Ellen, part 1 – Christians pray to Satan?
  • Abortion and Seventh-day Adventism
  • Why biological monogenism for humans is almost certain

Recent comments

  • Stephen Korsman on Thus saith Ellen, part 4 – The 10 commandments
  • Don Watson on Thus saith Ellen, part 4 – The 10 commandments
  • ASÍ DIJO ELENA G. WHITE, LA PROFETISA DEL ADVENTISMO DEL SÉPTIMO DÍA (Parte 1) – EL BLOG DEL APOLOGISTA CRISTIANO/ INGº. MARIO OLCESE SANGUINETI (LIMA/PERÚ) on Thus saith Ellen, part 1 – Christians pray to Satan?
  • Vjatjeslav on Abortion and Seventh-day Adventism
  • Stephen Korsman on Adventist abortion is the healing ministry of Jesus
  • Nick on Adventist abortion is the healing ministry of Jesus
  • Was Jesus the son of Mary? | Catholicism and Adventism on Mary, the Theotokos
  • Stephen Korsman on Jewish holy days fulfilled
  • Atmakur on Jewish holy days fulfilled
  • Free ebook – Catholic Discussion of Seventh-day Adventism | Catholicism and Adventism on Index – Catholic Discussion of Seventh-day Adventism

Archives

  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • October 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • June 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • December 2015
  • November 2015
  • October 2015
  • September 2015
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • May 2015
  • April 2015
  • November 2014
  • September 2014
  • August 2014
  • June 2014
  • May 2014
  • March 2014
  • February 2014
  • December 2013
  • November 2013
  • October 2013
  • September 2013
  • August 2013
  • July 2013
  • June 2013
  • May 2013
  • April 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013
  • September 2009
  • August 2009
  • February 2009
  • January 2009
  • December 2008
  • October 2008
  • September 2008
  • July 2008
  • June 2008
  • April 2008
  • July 2007
  • May 2007
  • April 2007
  • March 2007
  • February 2007
  • January 2007
  • December 2006
  • November 2006
  • October 2006
  • September 2006
  • August 2006
  • July 2006
  • June 2006
  • May 2006
  • April 2006
  • March 2006
  • February 2006
  • January 2006
  • December 2005
  • November 2005
  • October 2005
  • August 2005
  • July 2005
  • June 2005
  • December 2004
  • April 2004
  • February 2004
  • December 2003
  • November 2003
  • October 2003
  • February 2003
  • January 2003
  • November 2001
  • September 2001
  • August 2001
  • December 1999
  • April 1999
  • September 1998
  • July 1998
  • December 1997

Categories

  • Adventism
  • Blog admin
  • Catholic
  • Family
  • Liturgy
  • Other religions
  • Prophecy
  • Sabbath
  • Thus saith Ellen
  • Virology
  • What Catholics Believe

Tags

10 Commandments Abortion Adventism Adventist Anti-Catholic Apostles Bible Catholic Catholic Church Christian worship Church Fathers Conversion Daniel Dies Domini Diet Easter Ellen White Ellen White Eucharist First Day Gregorian University Holy Day Honest quoting Icons Jesus Law Mary Mass New Covenant Novena Old Covenant Orthodox Papacy Passover Pope Pope Benedict XVI Prophecy Resurrection Sabbath Saints Samuele Bacchiocchi Soul sleep Statues Sunday Trinity

Books I recommend

  • Books / videos

Blogs I read

  • Shameless Popery
  • Fr. Z’s Blog – What Does The Prayer Really Say?
  • Biblical Evidence for Catholicism
  • The Joys of Being Catholic
  • It’s Okay NOT to be a Seventh-day Adventist
  • The Eye of the Tiber
  • Bread from Heaven
  • Creative Minority Report
  • New Liturgical Movement
  • Etheldredasplace

Credits and info

  • Copyright
  • Credits
  • About me
  • Contact
Society blog
Fight Spam! Click Here!
« Adventist pastor gives an example of uninspired statements by Paul in the Bible
Another SDA, Pam, attacks the truth but refuses to discuss the Bible »

Constantine, the Papacy, and the real origins of Sunday

November 5, 2001
By Stephen Korsman
Fb-Button
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

This is an e-mail I wrote in response to a request for commentary got from Robert Sanders, who has a ministry for Adventists at his website Truth or Fables – his words are in green, my reply is in black.

Thanks for offering me the chance to explain how we Catholics feel about the Sabbath / Sunday “change.”

If I understand the Catholic position correctly, they say the Pope did not change the Seventh Day Sabbath to Sunday. They contend this was done by the Apostolic Church and there is no record of a “Pope” making the change, but it was done on authority of the Catholic Church.

Yes, that is pretty much the Catholic position summed up. We do, however, also hold to the idea that Sunday observance is biblical, and the origins are referenced in the New Testament (texts like Heb 4, Col 2, Rom 14, Gal 4, Acts 20, 1 Cor 16 and others.)

One must just be careful in defining one’s terms.

One person might say, “The Catholic Church changed the Sabbath” and another might say, “The Apostles changed the Sabbath” and depending on their background, they might mean the same thing, or they might be disagreeing with each other.

Some terms, as used by Catholicism in general, of interest:

– Catholic Church – this refers to the Church as begun by Christ and led by the Apostles after Pentecost
– Apostolic Church – this is a synonym for the Catholic Church during the time when the Apostles were alive
– post-Apostolic Church – the Catholic Church once the last Apostle had died
– papacy – the office of Peter instituted in Matt 16:18, and continued in his successors
– pope – the occupant of the papacy, beginning with Peter in the first century

I do not expect you to AGREE with these terms or accept the theology we Catholics accept. All I ask is that when you read Catholic texts written by Catholics, you TRY to understand what we are saying, instead of applying YOUR definitions for these words to something WE have written.

For instance, if a Catholic said, “SUNDAY IS A CATHOLIC INSTITUTION” (quotes from the original e-mail I am responding to) then this needs to be understood using Catholic definitions, in order to know what the Catholic means and understands. He is, therefore, NOT saying that Sunday observance began in 300 AD or 600 AD or whenever it might be that a Protestant feels the “Roman Catholic Church” <incorrect name, in fact> came into existence. What the Catholic is actually saying with “SUNDAY IS A CATHOLIC INSTITUTION” is that Sunday observance is something that came from the Catholic Church – without specifying era – and he would, in good conscience, say EXACTLY the same of the decision in Acts 15 about circumcision – he would claim that THAT TOO was a “Catholic institution” because that IS how he sees the early Christian Church – as Catholic.

What often happens, then, is that Catholics claim authorship to Sunday observance because they believe the Apostles began Sunday observance and they view the Apostles as the first Catholic leaders, but when Adventists hear these words, they grab them and remove their context and actual meaning, and make it seem as if the Catholic Church is claiming that Sunday observance was begun by a group which the Adventists define as the Catholic Church, and NOT the Apostolic Church.

That said, I must differentiate between THREE types of texts that can be used as evidence.

1. Statements by Catholics that a) agree with Catholic teaching but b) are not official sources of Catholic teaching
2. Statements by Catholics that disagree with Catholic teaching
3. Statements that constitute official Catholic teaching

I have almost NEVER seen Adventists quote official Catholic teaching on the issue of the Sabbath. (Simply because it would destroy what they want people to believe we teach.) On the rare occasion, one will quote the Catechism of the Catholic Church, and even more rarely, they will quote it in context. Virtually ALL of the quotes they offer to support their view, are quotes of type 2 (not real Catholic teaching) or type 1 quotes where context and the author’s intent have been abused.

Examples of texts of type 3 (official Catholic teaching) include:
– the Bible (Catholics DO view the Bible as an official source of truth)
– the Catechism of the Catholic Church
– papal encyclicals
– Council documents (e.g. from the Council of Nicaea, or the Council of Trent) – these include catechisms, decrees, canons, letters, etc produced by the council in question
– other official Vatican documents intended to convey or explain Catholic teaching

Examples of texts of type 1 (agree with Catholic teaching but the text itself is not authoritative) include:
– ALL Catholic newspapers
– ALL Catholic periodicals not published by the Vatican (and most which are, e.g. their tax report)
– books with “Imprimatur” printed in front (this is only permission to print, and says nothing about accuracy of content)
– books with “Nihil obstat” printed in front (this means that the book is considered to be faithful to Catholic teaching by the local bishop, NOT that the book is an official source of Catholic doctrine)
– many books whose titles contain the word “Catechism”
– my website (hopefully, I try to make it agree with Catholic teaching as far as I can)

Examples of type 2 texts, which disagree with Catholic teaching, include:
– the abundant quotes referenced from the Catholic Mirror newspaper
– other similar texts

Note: I have, on record, Adventist pastors who tell me that the Bible contains errors, that a lot of what Paul said we need not obey, that it was merely opinion. I have Adventist pastors who have told me that Ellen White is indeed infallible and has not erred, that she was inspired by God and that her writings CAN RIGHTLY be used to interpret difficult passages in the Bible (and by logical extension, faulty ones if the Bible contains error.) Do THESE quotes constitute “official Adventist teaching” just because they come from the mouth of an Adventist pastor? I doubt it. These statements would fall into the type 2 category I described above. By taking type 1 and type 2 statements and removing context, a strong straw-man case can be made for the opposing position – as long as the reader is kept ignorant of the true nature of these texts, and never shown any type 3 (official) texts which show authentic teaching of the respective denomination. I will send, just after this, a case study I have put together on this, which will hopefully demonstrate the error in the pseudo-Catholic propaganda that many Sabbatarians spread.

For a full view of Catholic teaching on the origins of the observance of Sunday, and the removal of the Sabbath observance, I recommend you read the papal encyclical Dies Domini, written by Pope John Paul II.

If this is true, then Ellen White is wrong in saying it was changed by “THE POPE.”

Ellen White would have defined the term “the pope” differently to Catholics – she would likely have meant someone other than the Apostle Peter, someone who lived much later in Christian history. She should name him, and she does not.

It is interesting that the SDA Church cannot put a name on the Pope that made the change.

That IS interesting :-> Certainly it shows that they are prepared to make claims, but can’t give details when the claims are questioned by informed questioners.

Updates on the pope who (didn’t) change the Sabbath

Pope Sylvester I – who changed the Sabbath?
More on Sunday and Pope Sylvester I

Your reaction to this post:
  • I agree ()
  • I disagree ()
  • I am not sure ()
  • Awesome ()
  • Interesting ()
  • Boring ()

More from my site

  • More on Sunday and Pope Sylvester IMore on Sunday and Pope Sylvester I
  • Pope Sylvester I – who changed the Sabbath?Pope Sylvester I – who changed the Sabbath?
  • What Catholics Believe – Sunday observanceWhat Catholics Believe – Sunday observance
  • Is Saturday the True Sabbath?Is Saturday the True Sabbath?
  • The Passover of the JewsThe Passover of the Jews
  • Jewish holy days fulfilledJewish holy days fulfilled
Fb-Button

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google
  • Reddit
  • Pinterest

Tags: Adventist, Apostles, Catholic Church, Church Fathers, Dies Domini, Honest quoting, Pope, Pope Sylvester I, Resurrection, Sabbath, Sunday

« Adventist pastor gives an example of uninspired statements by Paul in the Bible
Another SDA, Pam, attacks the truth but refuses to discuss the Bible »
Flag Counter

Copyright © 2018 Catholicism and Adventism. All Rights Reserved.
Magazine Basic theme designed by Themes by bavotasan.com.
Powered by WordPress.
»
«